Syndicate of Shadows|Site Info
Main Forum

Recruitment application

Mark Unread · 4 replies
As this forum implies, this is a suggestion only.

When I applied to SoS (can I call it that?), I felt that the application wasn't very in-depth, it didn't explore the person behind the character. Now, granted, our current requirements are rather lax because we're building the guild, but I'd like to propose a few changes:

- I think the first question, "How did you hear about Syndicate of Shadows," could be reduced to checkboxes or radio buttons intead of an open textbox. An option for "other" and a small textbox for explanations could be introduced but, if I were developing an application, I would try to make it as manageable as possible.

- I would add another open question or two. It's been my experience that good writing correlates with, well, intelligence, of course, but maturity level. I want good, decent people in SoS; play skill is secondary to me. I'm not certain if that aligns with the guild's values, but that's what's important to me. Maybe "What do you want to accomplish in the game?" or "Why are you playing SWTOR?" or even a "Tell us about yourself."

- I think the availability questions imply a certain hard-core-ness of us and I don't think that's what we want to convey. If we dedicate too much of our application to play time, we might give the impression that we want them on all the time, or as much as possible. I was a little taken aback and didn't quite know how to answer. I did check all the boxes because I am able to play everyday, but it's only in the evenings. I didn't want to give the wrong idea so, I explained my answer in the "How many hours..." question. I'm not sure if it accepted my answer. It may have just returned an "error: this person is an idiot" message, which is true and I appreciate you overlooking this and inviting me anyway.

This merits another tl;dr: checkboxes for "How did you hear..." and moar open ended questions, less availability ones.

P.S. Can an admin move this post and/or change view permissions so that guests can't see this, please?
Posted Dec 27, 11 · OP · Last edited Dec 29, 11
0 votes
Gooder words never herd :d But honestly, good suggestions.
Posted Dec 27, 11
0 votes
57 posts
0 votes
Moderator
These are excellent points and I can only take this as constructive criticism. I admit I was haste in the application process because of the time press of release date. I will take word you typed into account and plan a revised version. Any help from ANY members is greatly appreciated.

I'm lucky to come across so many dedicated people so early in the game to only want to help better this guild. Thank you guys.
a1c3bb97ef74ba6b.png
Posted Dec 29, 11
0 votes
57 posts
0 votes
Moderator
Update: I did a quick revision and would like for you guys to look over the application for me and let me know what you think. Also, would like to know if I should leave this question in the application as it could spark the "hardcore-feel" as mention above: "What is your previous MMO experience and how long did you play in each MMO?"

Get back to me on this.
a1c3bb97ef74ba6b.png
Posted Dec 29, 11
0 votes
Looks good! I think that question is valid. As video games have become more mainstream, it's more common to have previous experience. First-time gamers know this and are often introduced to games by someone they know, who has been playing more than he should *looks away.* We just have to be certain that s/he knows that we're *not* hardcore and that we know RL > game. It should be on the website and/or the application and it should be mentioned in our advertisements in-game and out.

Also, not to sound picky but, in the first two sections please make "aspiring member" plural and correct "Initiate" in "To become an Initiatie"

Nice job!
Posted Dec 29, 11 · OP
0 votes
Announcement of